Thursday , April 25th 2019
Practice Areas

April 22, 2008 - Fraud Claim Rejected In Hurricane Katrina Lawsuit

A federal judge on Monday dismissed a key Hurricane Katrina lawsuit alleging fraud against State Farm Fire & Casualty Co. The suit was filed by Biloxi, Mississippi couple Thomas and Pamela McIntosh, after State Farm blamed most of the damage to their home on Katrina's storm surge, and paid them only $36,228. Dozens of lawsuits were filed in the wake of Hurricane Katrina's devastation of the gulf coast on August 29, 2005. Many of them, the McIntosh's included, centered around allegations that State Farm routinely denied claims based on bad faith and fraud.

The McIntosh suit claimed that State Farm, through Alabama-based firm A.E. Renfroe & Company, who provided State Farm with damage assessment reports, produced two separate engineering reports in October 2005, shortly after the Katrina damage occurred. They alleged that State Farm used the two reports to minimize the value of the wind damage sustained by their home and to avoid liability for their claims against their homeowners' policy. The couples' policy did not include coverage for flood damage.

In his Partial Summary Judgment, U.S. District Court Judge L.T. Senter, Jr., says that while the McIntosh's contention that State Farm and A.E. Renfroe worked together to deliberately underestimate the damage to their home would support a finding of bad faith, it is not sufficient to warrant such a finding. A.E. Renfroe & Company, he further finds, cannot have aided and abetted a fraud that did not occur.

<< back

The above is not legal advice. That can only come from a qualified attorney who is familiar with all the facts and circumstances of a particular, specific case and the relevant law. See Terms of Use.

Contact Us

For questions about personal injury laws, fill out the form below or contact us by phone.

Law Offices of
Fuentes & Berrio.LLP

709 E. Hillsboro Blvd.
Deerfield Beach, FL 33441

(877) 354-LAWS
Toll Free
(954) 752-1110
Broward County
(305) 931-2002
Miami Dade
(561) 279-2424
Palm Beach
(352) 387-1000
Martin County
(954) 794-1212
If you would like to contact us or have us review your case, please fill out the form below.

Home | About us | contact us | newsletter | ESPAÑOL

Copyright © 2008 Fuentes & Berrio, L.L.P., All rights reserved | Developed by LawyerEdge